Harry Moroz
Swiped! Did The Credit Card Industry Just Hijack Credit Card Reform Legislation?
The prevailing wisdom in this week’s press reports about credit card reform legislation now being debated in the Senate is that Senator Dodd’s version is stronger than the Credit Cardholders’ Bill of Rights, which passed the House easily last month. The New York Times’ Carl Hulse concluded:
[The Senate bill] goes farther than a measure already easily passed by the House in imposing an array of new restrictions on credit card companies.
Politico’s Victoria McGrane was slightly more accurate:
The compromise [between Banking Committee mates Senator Dodd and Republican Senator Richard Shelby] softened some provisions in Dodd’s original bill — which came out of committee without a single Republican vote — but still would give the industry a stronger dose of medicine than the bill passed by the House last month.
As far as they go, these reports are not inaccurate, but they tell far from the whole story. Indeed, the current version of the Dodd bill is significantly weaker than the version that was passed by the Banking Committee. Indeed, the Dodd-Shelby compromise looks very, very similar to Rep. Maloney’s bill of rights. The real story is the direction in which compromising with Senator Shelby pulled Senator Dodd. That is, in the direction of the credit card companies.
The Credit Card Accountability, Responsibility, and Disclosure Act, though an important milestone in consumer protections, exhibits the signs of the credit card industry’s powerful influence. Unlike the previous version, the bill likely to be passed by the Senate does not explicitly prohibit universal default, the practice whereby a credit card company uses information unrelated to a consumer’s credit card as the basis for increasing the interest rate. Instead, card companies are left to decide for themselves when improvements in a cardholder’s credit warrant a rate reduction. The previous version, like the House version, limit the number of over-the-limit fees – fees applied when a cardholder charges more than their card limit – that card companies can apply. This version does not.
Instead of outright prohibition of abusively high fees, the Credit Card Accountability, Responsibility, and Disclosure Act requires that fees be reasonable and proportional; the card industry, with easy access to political power, will determine what “reasonable and proportional” mean. Though the Act improves oversight of the credit card industry, the previous version required the collection of comprehensive and detailed information about an industry whose practices are at best opaque and at worst purposefully deceptive.
While compromise is necessary to the legislative process, in this case compromise seems to have been largely one-sided.
Harry Moroz: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 4:28 PM, May 14, 2009 in Civil Justice | Consumers | Corporate Accountability
Permalink | Email to Friend | Comments (13)
Comments
Where is the information about the attachment for guns in our national parks on this credit card (NO) bill?
Posted by: Sandra Holt | May 20, 2009 09:06 PM
good blog interesting to knw so many thgs abt credit cards
Posted by: best credit card deal | October 4, 2009 02:19 AM
interesting thgs abt credit cards, ppl dont knw the hidden hazards of credit cards
Posted by: credit card offers | October 4, 2009 02:24 AM
This blog had helped me a lot in finding best credit card present in the market and also helped me in finding pros and cons of deals
===========================================
kevin
Best credit card
Posted by: kevin | February 4, 2010 06:40 AM
nice article.
____________
Ashish
http://www.financehelpdirect.com
Posted by: Ashish | February 18, 2010 08:36 AM
nice article.
____________
Ashish
http://www.financehelpdirect.com
Posted by: Ashish | February 18, 2010 08:37 AM
Indeed, the Dodd-Shelby compromise looks very, very similar to Rep.........
jsmith
thanks
...............................
Compare Credit Cards
Posted by: jsmith | March 5, 2010 05:30 AM
This blog had helped me a lot in finding best credit card.
Best Credit Card
Posted by: Best Credit Card | April 28, 2010 06:30 AM
this blog is very useful.This blog had helped me a lot in finding best credit card.
Best Credit Card
Posted by: Best Credit Card | April 28, 2010 06:33 AM
I think you need to completely believe in your product first of all and believe the its the best in all. Then for sure you come across to your customers with full determination and confidence and they'll have faith in you. Just remember that you and your product are the Best!
==========================
Compare Credit Card Offers
Posted by: sunny sengar | May 3, 2010 01:51 AM
Thanks for the information. It is a great post. It has helped me deal with my credit card issues.
Credit Card Deals
*************
Alyssa
Posted by: Credit Card Deals | June 22, 2010 08:38 AM
The government has given free credit report - how you see your free annual credit report free ads on television do not really offer a credit report is attached to the Federal Trade Commission has appointed a single site. All three credit reports and all 3 credit scores online 3-in-1 credit report and 3 credit points from TransUnion, Equifax and Experian online credit report and your credit score and get monitoring. free credit report instantly receive your credit score and credit report free tools free credit card online to track and optimize your credit score no credit card required and no hidden fees.
=============================================
Free Credit Report
Posted by: Free Credit Report | July 27, 2010 02:19 AM
I am very pleased with the thought and don’t feel like adding
anything in it. It a perfect answer.
---------
Finance
Posted by: tanmay | August 31, 2010 09:19 PM