Harry Moroz
Is Obama Really a Budget Hawk?
As President-elect Obama outlines his plans for economic stimulus – or economic “recovery” as the Times’s Carl Hulse noted rather cheekily this morning – he has been singing paeans to budget hawks concerned that profligate spending in the short term will produce, well, profligate spending in the long term. Politico found him “wooing” Blue Dog Democrats, who have periodically thrown a wrench in House-Senate negotiations about stimulus (er, recovery) and about other spending increases like the energy bill attached to the Wall St. bailout (er, rescue).
Rachel Maddow pointed out several nights ago that Obama’s economic team is heavily influenced by “Rubinomics”, the economic philosophy of the budget-conscious Clinton Treasury Secretary. And his selection of Peter Orszag as budget director (“a favorite of fiscal conservatives” but, let’s not forget, also a health care whiz) is another sign of his commitment to budget austerity.
This push and pull between fiscal hawks and those more willing to spend is by no means a new debate. Certainly, most probably agree that trillion dollar bailouts and hundreds of billions of dollars in stimulus spending are not sustainable.
But Politico and others have been too quick to associate Obama with the budget hawks.
The president-elect seems to be focused on more than increases and decreases in spending, a framing conservatives and Blue Dogs use to describe just about all government programs. Instead, Obama seems intent on budget reform, rather than only creating “savings” from spending cuts. He seems interested in creating a budget that evaluates the usefulness of program outcomes in relation to their costs. This may seem obvious - but for some time fiscal conservatives have painted any federal spending as profligate.
In Tuesday’s press conference, Obama stated:
In these challenging times, when we’re facing both rising deficits and a shrinking economy, budget reform is not an option. It’s a necessity...[The Office of Management and Budget] will not only help design a budget and manage its implementation, but it's also going to make sure that our government -- your government -- is more efficient and more effective at serving the American people.
Obama's not just calling for budget cuts with a scalpel. Instead of evaluating government programs based on government revenue and expenditure alone, Obama seems to be (I hope) suggesting that his budget will consider the returns to investment created by this government spending.
Perhaps I’m reading too much into Obama’s statements. But, as Matthew Berger pointed out with certain astonishment at Marc Ambinder’s blog yesterday, Obama announced his budget director and deputy director at a press conference before he named his secretary of state.
Harry Moroz: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 11:36 AM, Nov 26, 2008 in Economy | Governmental Reform
Permalink | Email to Friend | Comments (2)
Comments
Keeping our environment green and payday loans have certainly provided that extra cash flow I desperately needed. It’s a wonderful thing that more and more people are wising up and advocating better protection to our planet. Yet there are still many people who need to be educated on the importance of living in green. It's not that difficult to put a little effort to save the earth, and make money at the same time. I probably won’t be getting a new hybrid car anytime soon, but there are other simple and inexpensive things that I do on a daily basis that keeps me going green. I make sure to switch off anything electronic if it is not in use, such as the T.V., lights, and even the heater. Since then, my electric bill has dropped significantly. I guess it helps that I’m a little compulsive when it comes to organizing. I enjoy separating every recyclable item into individual bins. It looks neat and makes it a lot easier for the recycling companies. I’ve trained my kids to collect all the aluminum cans around the house. When they’ve collected enough, we take the cans to the recycling station to redeem a certain amount of money for each pound of aluminum we bring in. However, I am so thrilled because I learned something new in an article I read. I wasn’t aware that people are also recycling cell phones. I can finally make money off of the many old cell phones I have tucked away in a drawer. Any extra cash I can make will help a great deal. I also found some great ideas that will come in handy during this holiday season. I can save money by using things around the house for gift-wraps, instead of spending a large amount on new accessories that will only be thrown out. I have old ribbons and strings in a huge container, and I know the attic is filled with tons of shoeboxes, which will make perfect homemade gift boxes. The extra cash I save will provide the budget help we need, especially with the way the economy is going. Of course, these tricks will help me out in many different areas, but winter is upon us and I know bigger bills are on the way. I know the extra green I do make by recycling won’t cover all of my bills. Good thing payday loans are available to maintain the green in my budget. Click here to learn more about Payday Loans.
Posted by: Payday Loans | December 2, 2008 05:48 AM
Current economic conditions have put the federal government under great pressure and strain. On one hand you have failed corporations, who are too big to fall and the government has to rescue them. So the government is in a position of a hostage by big corporations. On the other hand, you have various programs that need financing, states that are in trouble and need financial help from the government, various infrastructure and other programs (new ones as well) and not enough money. Makes sense to start prioritizing and also start thinking how to control these costs and cut back on some of them, so we don’t wind up in a situation when the government simply needs to print more money, in order to meet its obligations.
Posted by: David Dzidzikashvili | May 7, 2009 05:34 PM