DMI Blog

Amy Traub

My Tax Cut Can Beat Up Your Tax Cut

In the Bush playbooks, tax cuts are the cure for all that ails America. Need health care? Take a tax cut. Troubled economy? More tax cuts Early in his presidency, Bush even proposed tax credits as a solution for the nation’s education problems.

By this time, it’s no shocker that John McCain is aping the tax-cuts-solve-everything mantra of the Bush Administration (not to mention it’s flip side: all-taxes-are-bad). The surprising thing is how much hold this anti-tax rhetoric has over the Obama campaign.

Don’t get me wrong: Obama’s policy plans go well beyond tax cuts for every situation. He’s smart about public investment for a wide range of critical needs and acknowledges that this requires revenue (guess where that comes from?) But a top feature on the Obama campaign website still plays the right-wing anti-tax game: my tax cut is bigger than your tax cut. For the vast majority Americans, it is. But that’s not the point.

When DMI surveyed middle-class Americans this summer, we found almost no one concerned about taxes. 46% said the economy and jobs were a top concern (the Bush record suggests tax cuts do a lousy job of addressing those worries), 35% were preoccupied with gas prices (despite McCain’s efforts to sell us otherwise, tax cuts wouldn’t have helped there either). The War in Iraq, health care, national security, education, immigration… all ranked higher than taxes. The bottom line? Just 4% of middle-class Americans thought taxes were a top issue facing the country.

So why do tax cuts persist in taking center stage in both campaigns? For Obama, it looks like a defensive action. He expected to get painted with the brush of a tax-and-spend Democrat and worked proactively to head off the accusation. But in the process, his campaign inevitably feeds into that same tired tax-cuts-solve-everything/all-taxes-are-bad chestnut.

The fact may be that we can’t expect presidential campaigns – which after all, must focus on winning elections – to reorient our nation’s political dialogue. Instead, it’s up to progressives to start laying the groundwork now so that next election, and the one after that, we’re not still stuck with a political conversation that begins and ends with who wants to raise your taxes. Let’s get to work.

Amy Traub: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 4:34 PM, Oct 21, 2008 in Election 2008 | Tax Policy
Permalink | Email to Friend