Harry Moroz
Racial Profiling Will “Save” Our Cities: A New Urban Agenda
Last week, Manhattan Institute Scholar Heather Mac Donald wrote an op-ed in The Washington Post calling out Senator Obama for failing to embrace “accountable, data-driven policing” in outlining his urban agenda to the U.S. Conference of Mayors last month. Ms. Mac Donald cites such policing as one of the primary reasons for New York City's comeback in the 1990s. (Data-driven policing seems awfully like racial profiling, to me. Oh yeah, Ms. Mac Donald wrote "The Myth of Racial Profiling" a few years back.)
Indeed, in the article she attacks:
[t]he received wisdom of the Great Society...that crime could be lowered only by eliminating its “root causes”: poverty and racism.
But Ms. Mac Donald's vision for cities doesn't end there. Instead of implementing an urban agenda that relies on state and local governments to plan and grow regional economies, Ms. Mac Donald suggested:
The best urban renewal strategy Obama could adopt would be to rebut the false charge that the criminal justice system is racist.
The piece’s argument against a federal agenda for cities is outdated and reinforces stereotypes that have for years simplistically identified urban areas with minorities, poverty, and crime. As Senator Obama emphasized in his speech to the Mayor’s Conference, cities and metropolitan areas may still contain the impoverished, but they are in fact defined by the solutions they offer to problems of economic stagnation, climate change, and globalization. And as Mayor L. Douglas Wilder of Richmond told me at the same Conference, “You can’t define problems anymore as urban problems or suburban problems.”
To assert that the best strategy for urban renewal is “to rebut the false charge that the criminal justice system is racist” is simply to insert racial politics into a debate more properly about multimodal transportation, green buildings, and sewage systems. Of course, removing the racial lens from Ms. Mac Donald’s argument somehow makes a federal urban agenda much more attractive, if less controversial.
Harry Moroz: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 5:25 PM, Jul 28, 2008 in Cities | MayorTV | Urban Affairs
Permalink | Email to Friend | Comments (2)











Comments
Heather MacDonald is the White Citizens' Council to Michael Savage's KKK. She never uses racial slurs; instead, she justifies every act of police brutality against unarmed civilians, and explains patiently how black people really deserve what they get.
Posted by: Alon Levy | July 29, 2008 12:25 AM
Even if evidence based policing has played a role in the crime drop it has done nothing to address many of the major problems facing cities, especially New York. Despite falling crime (which has happened in cities without evidenced based policing) New York is experiencing record levels of homelessness and hunger. Hundreds of thousands are ill housed and up to one million New Yorkers have relied on food pantries or soup kitchens in the last year. In addition, median incomes for the poor and middle classes have fallen consistently over the last generation, even when the economy expands. Aggressive policing has done nothing to address these harsh financial realities and Heather McDonald's job is to obscure these facts with a lot of race bating and reactionary pro-law and order fear mongering.
Posted by: Alex S. Vitale | August 8, 2008 09:43 AM