DMI Blog

Andrea Batista Schlesinger

DMI Sends Members of Congress Home with Their 2007 Grades!

If the middle class could give your Congressmember a grade, what would it be? Today, DMI releases grades for every senator and representative, evaluating their votes on key legislation that affects the current and aspiring middle class.

Picture 1.png2007 began as a year of great promise. Congress was flooded with dozens of new members, many elected with a pledge to address the middle-class squeeze and help more working people attain a middle-class standard of living. Important legislation—from expanding children’s health coverage to bringing down the cost of college loans—was introduced and brought to a vote. But, faced with Senate filibusters and a recalcitrant President, many bills died or were passed in watered-down form. Still, the bills that did become law represent concrete gains for current and aspiring middle-class Americans, including a higher minimum wage, expanded Pell Grants, a freeze on middle class tax hikes and lower costs to fuel cars.

TheMiddleClass.org 2007 Congressional Scorecard takes a closer look at the decisions made by Congress, from the one-year freeze to prevent the Alternative Minimum Tax from hitting middle-class families to the filibuster that originally torpedoed a minimum wage increase (later passed) and the trade bill that put the interests of multinational corporations and large investors before the concerns of middle-class Americans.

After examining 13 bills in detail, the 2007 Congressional Scorecard assigns a grade to each Member of Congress based on his or her support for the middle class. On the whole, Congress squeaked by with a passing grade in 2007, but there is considerable room for improvement. Just 62% of Representatives and 56% of Senators received a C or better. While this middle-class record is far better than the first term of the 109th Congress, the millions of Americans striving to attain—or hold onto—a middle-class standard of living deserve more from their elected representatives.

In an effort to hold Congress accountable to the middle class, DMI bought a Google ad for each and every member of Congress, which will show up on the right side of the screen. Each ad includes the legislator's letter grade and a link to their own personal page on TheMiddleClass.org.

But what can you do with this veritable treasure trove of information, you ask? The possibilities are endless. Create your own new-and-improved personal widget for your blog, and feature the names of your state's senators and representatives or issues of importance. Bloggers can use the grades when writing about any Congressmember and how they rank on middle class issues. Read about the best and worst bills of the year, and find out how Congress stacked up. Link to analysis of the bills on the scorecard on TheMiddleClass.org.

Congress, we're watching you, and so are millions of Google-searchers who see the Google ads. So check out the grades, link to them, Google them, and do your part to hold Congress accountable.

Andrea Batista Schlesinger: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 6:44 AM, Mar 12, 2008 in TheMiddleClass.org
Permalink | Email to Friend | Comments (2)


Comments

Obama gets an A+ while Durbin gets an A?

Demonstrates that not counting missed votes skews the results. With 4 missed votes, Obama came dangerously close to an INC mark. With perfect attendance, Durbin voted incorrectly on one of the thirteen bills used in grading. I submit that Obama's four implicit nay votes had a greater impact. In fact, one of the absences was the very same bill on which Durbin incorrectly voted nay. Fair is fair. When I was in school, if you missed a test, you got a zero.

Posted by: Lawrence Johnson | March 17, 2008 08:39 AM

The way missed votes are counted does impact the results, although I would not say they are skewed. Failing to cast a vote on a bill has a very different impact on the passage of legislation than voting "no" -- it's not an implicit "nay" vote and even less an implicit vote against the middle-class position (which is sometimes yea and sometimes nay, depending on the bill).

The rules about incompletes affect some legislators positively and others negatively. Consider Senator Schumer for example. He voted against the middle-class position on only one bill, which normally would get him an A grade. But he also missed one vote, so his score is calculated as 8/9 rather than 9/10, and as a result he gets a B. In Senator Obama's case, as you note, he missed several votes but is left with an A+ score. The same is true of several others who were away from the Senate campaigning for president in 2007, including Senators Clinton, Biden, and Dodd. Senator McCain missed so many votes that he receives an incomplete grade.

Posted by: Amy Traub | March 17, 2008 11:40 AM


Post a comment

Verification: